Welcome!

Each week we bring to you a discussion on the latest trends in digital marketing and how you can actually implement these strategies into your organization.

#150 Marketing for Impact: UNICEF’s Blueprint for Change with Shelley Diamond

“Impact can be measured purely in dollars, or it can be measured in impact, which is the effect that our programs have had on changing the lives of children.” -Shelley Diamond
Shelley Diamond is a passionate builder of global brands and businesses, with expertise across a wide range of communications disciplines. As one of the highest-ranking female executives in advertising, she has championed marketing transformation for both domestic and global clients in the consumer and B2B spaces. In this interview, Shelley emphasizes that marketing should be viewed as an investment—integral to achieving real impact through advocacy and program success—not simply as an expense on the balance sheet. She shares how UNICEF approaches innovation through program effectiveness, leveraging technology, partnerships, and bold action to further children’s rights, education, and well-being. This includes adapting to modern challenges such as combating misinformation and navigating difficult terrains for vaccine delivery. Shelley explains how UNICEF integrates brand and performance marketing, using data-driven insights to identify and target audiences most likely to engage with and support their mission. By expanding their reach and tailoring their approach to different audience interests, UNICEF remains relevant and impactful in a crowded nonprofit space—while balancing the sector’s focus on expense versus program ratio. This conversation offers valuable lessons for anyone looking to align brand building with measurable, meaningful change.

About the Episode

Welcome to a behind-the-scenes look at how UNICEF—one of the world’s most trusted and iconic humanitarian organizations—has transformed and supercharged its brand and marketing approach to make a deeper impact on children worldwide. This detailed blog post draws from an honest, engaging conversation with Shelley Diamond, a leading voice in UNICEF’s marketing and innovation journey. If you’re curious about how nonprofits can embrace business thinking, why brand matters just as much in charity as in commerce, and how innovation really works in crisis-driven sectors, pull up a chair and get ready to dive in.

Introduction: From Y&R to UNICEF

Shelley Diamond’s journey into UNICEF began with a long career at Y&R (Young & Rubicam), clocking nearly three decades. Nonprofit work was always her passion, and she spent years involved in ad council projects and social-impact campaigns.

“Our CEO was passionate about changing the world and making it a better place. In 2016, we started a nonprofit practice within Y&R to help nonprofits think about their organizations as companies, as for-profit businesses.”

After the 2016 election, nonprofits faced a tough outlook for fundraising. Shelley’s CEO, David Sable, sat on UNICEF’s board and saw an opportunity: “How would you like to help them out?” That dream quickly became reality—Shelley came on first as an advisor, then joined full-time. Five years later, she’s never felt happier, prouder, or more equipped for her role. Especially now, with everything going on in the world for children, her passion for the UNICEF mission only grows.

UNICEF as a Brand: Meeting a New Generation

If you grew up in the U.S., you probably remember UNICEF’s orange Trick-or-Treat boxes. That’s trust and recognition, right? But as Shelley notes, being familiar isn’t enough to keep the flame alive—especially when newer organizations like Patagonia, with flashy causes and youth-oriented energy, are snagging the attention of a new generation.

“Organizations like that [Patagonia] for a new generation are more likely to attract supporters who want to change the world around climate than giving money to UNICEF or Greenpeace. So we had to say, look, we are a brand. That’s where our strength lies.”

UNICEF had to pivot. They needed to educate audiences—especially younger supporters—that building a nonprofit brand wasn’t about handouts, but about driving real results and impact.

The Brand Audit: Fixing Fatigue and Tapping into Trust

In Shelley’s early days at UNICEF, the team undertook a thorough brand study. The results? UNICEF was a very trusted brand, and people were familiar with it—but this “familiarity” often stopped short at those classic orange boxes.

“We were a very trusted brand. People were familiar with us, but that familiarity was completely connected to trick-or-treating with a little orange box… We needed to do something really significant to reignite the power of the UNICEF brand.”

The challenge was clear: reignite the brand, modernize the story, and create forward momentum. Working with clever data analysts and a bold executive team, UNICEF developed a new brand positioning in 2018.

Powering Up the Mission: Storytelling, Scale, and Action

Shelley sums up UNICEF’s culture perfectly:

“UNICEF is a bunch of badass do-gooders. We have to bring innovation, we have to bring some feeling of modern, forward momentum to a brand that does so much and people know so little.”

What sets UNICEF apart? Its scale—thousands of passionate workers tackle crises around the globe, from dropping supplies in remote areas via drones to braving frontline danger. Shelley describes these heroes as “Mother Teresa meets Raiders of the Lost Ark.” The stories were there; they just needed to be told.

This internal embrace of the revitalized brand unlocked not only staff enthusiasm but became a key strategy enabler shaping every aspect of UNICEF’s approach.

Innovation in Humanitarian Marketing

So what does innovation really mean in a charity, especially one as established as UNICEF?

Shelley sets the record straight:

“It’s so easy to say, ‘We want to be innovative.’ Well, no. Could you imagine interviewing a CMO who doesn’t want to be innovative? That would be pretty scary.”

They built innovation right into UNICEF’s cultural DNA with three core values:

  • Everything through the lens of children and their rights
  • The Power of We: Changing the world takes all of us—corporate, donors, teams
  • Big Thinking, Bold Action: Making space to try, fail, learn, and repeat

And that means giving team members freedom to experiment, to test new ideas, and most importantly the latitude to occasionally fail—a tough but necessary ethic in the nonprofit sector.

Big Thinking, Bold Action: UNICEF’s Core Values

Let’s break these big ideas down a bit further:

1. The Children’s Rights Lens

In the U.S. (and globally), talking about children’s rights is delicate. UNICEF must always balance advocacy with sensitivity to local and international perspectives.

2. The Power of We

No single person or entity can tackle the world’s problems alone; real change comes from coalition-building—enlisting help from corporate partners, donors, innovators, and everyday supporters.

3. Big Thinking, Bold Action

Innovation isn’t just a buzzword at UNICEF; it’s about giving people in the organization permission to think big, try bold solutions, and yes, sometimes fail.

“How do you get innovation? It’s not, you know, a bunch of really smart tech guys coming up with AI. Okay, I got it. Everybody wants to do something with AI. But for us, it means getting to more children, making our programs more effective.

Program-Level Innovation: Real Examples from the Field

How does innovation actually show up? It starts at the program level, supporting marketing efforts but rooted in fieldwork. For instance:

  • Improving girls’ access to education where it’s restricted (like Afghanistan)
  • Using digital technology and remote learning to reach children banned from schools
  • Employing cash transfers to pay teachers and support education continuity
  • Building bridges with governments—even difficult ones—to advance children’s rights and mental health
  • Distributing vaccines—and fighting misinformation—in war zones and remote areas

“Innovation for us is getting to more children, making programs more effective so we can ultimately change lives. Innovation can manifest in different ways.”

Digital Transformation: Trick-or-Treat, QR Codes & Engagement

One standout example: UNICEF’s classic Trick-or-Treat campaign, now totally digital, bringing new supporters onto the brand.

  • Trick-or-Treat is now a fully digital experience
  • QR codes on virtual boxes add interactivity and fun
  • Interactive videos give families and kids meaningful, educational entertainment
  • Engagement spikes at Halloween, using UNICEF’s “cultural currency”

“We spend our brand dollars in October because Halloween is by far the biggest holiday—forget about Christmas, it’s all about Halloween. The audiences are open. We’re culturally current.”

This digital push isn’t just about donations; it’s about building relationships, giving people things to do, and opening the door for deeper engagement.

Families might watch videos, download a Trick-or-Treat box, or interact without donating—but it sets the stage for future support and lasting affinity.

Performance Marketing Meets Brand: Attribution & Growth

Nonprofits have to show tangible results—dollars in, dollars out—but how can you link fuzzy brand marketing with razor-sharp donation results?

“Understanding that, you know, at the core of what we do is our audience. It’s not what we want them to do, it’s what they want to do and they’re in control. What they say and what they do are two very different things.”

UNICEF is refining a custom attribution model to:

  • Track donor journeys across digital, social, and campaign touchpoints
  • Separate “mid-funnel” (brand engagement) from “bottom funnel” (donation conversion)
  • Retarget new, interested audiences in December following brand-building in October/November
  • Use Harris Poll and similar data for audience segmentation and outcome tracking

“The more familiar you become with us … the more likely you are to consider. So that’s a real metric. Now we can retarget those people during the month of December and we can show that X amount of dollars came through new audiences.”

This thoughtful strategy helps UNICEF stretch limited marketing dollars and grow its base beyond the small group of “always-on” donors.

Marketing as Investment, Not Expense

Here’s a point every nonprofit needs to hear: marketing isn’t just a cost, but an investment in long-term growth and mission impact.

“Looking at this as an expense prevents you from how much you can invest. Yet if you really change that metric, we would be able to significantly expand our audience. Long-term growth of the organization would be significantly better.”

Traditional reporting standards (like Charity Navigator ratings) force demand-gen spend to appear as an expense, while brand, education, and advocacy are seen as core program costs. Shelley argues hard for measurement that reflects impact, not just revenue—whether that’s through donations or life-changing advocacy outcomes.

“Impact can be measured in dollars or in … the effect that our programs have had on changing the lives of children. And that includes things that are not donor funded, like advocacy actions.”

For example, changing policy in a country so girls’ education is funded—scholarships, digital literacy, reproductive rights—these are programmatic value, but measured differently from donation-driven growth.

How UNICEF Manages Real-Time Content

UNICEF USA isn’t just a fundraising org—they function like a newsroom, creating and sharing content around the clock, amplifying stories both on owned and paid channels.

  • The organization recently overhauled its website, designed largely in-house: unicefusa.org
  • Original content, breaking news, and stories are pushed out to supporters every day
  • When global crises hit—from Ukraine to Gaza—UNICEF deploys rapid-response teams and shares updates minute-by-minute
  • Paid amplification and PR outreach keep stories circulating, boosting engagement and visibility

“We really have some incredibly talented people… We see ourselves both as our organization marketing and as a newsroom pushing out content—mean not every day, every minute, being on literally 24/7.”

The team listens closely to audience reactions, retargets content that resonates, and always offers actions—whether to learn, advocate, or support.

Staying Mission-Focused Amidst Global Crisis

Global humanitarian work means walking a tightrope during polarized times—especially with conflicts and disasters like those in the Middle East, Ukraine, and Afghanistan.

Shelley’s take is blunt:

“We live in a world where just the horror around what Hamas did in Israel, but then the horror what’s happening in Gaza and you have an American public deeply divided. And we are not. We’re back to mission. Our mission is to save the lives of every child. That’s our mission.”

UNICEF keeps its message focused: saving children, wherever they are. Field teams report in real-time, stories are shared instantly, and the mission never shifts due to public emotion or divisive headlines.

Links, Resources, and How to Get Involved

Ready to learn more, support UNICEF’s work, or get involved? Check out these resources:

  • UNICEF USA: unicefusa.org
    • Stunning new website packed with stories, opportunities, and innovative engagement tools
  • Global UNICEF: unicef.org
    • Instantly shares global content with U.S. audiences, keeping everyone connected
  • Follow on Social Media: Twitter, Instagram, Facebook—search for UNICEF USA
  • Take Action: Engage through advocacy, policy campaigns, volunteering, or donate

Conclusion: Lessons From Shelley’s Interview

Shelley’s journey and UNICEF’s transformation offer incredible lessons for anyone in nonprofit, business, or marketing:

  • Treat your nonprofit like a business: Build your brand, invest in thoughtful strategy, and don’t be afraid of innovation.
  • Make culture count: Embed values—like “big thinking, bold action”—into daily work.
  • Measure what matters: Move beyond expenses and focus on tangible impact for communities.
  • Stay mission-focused: Even in a divided world, put purpose at the center.
  • Content is king (and queen): Keep stories fresh, relevant, and real-time.

And most of all? Never stop learning, testing, experimenting, and listening to the very people you aim to help.

Explore more and stay inspired. UNICEF’s story proves that with courage, creativity, and care, even the most trusted brand can find new life—and change the world for generations to come.

More Episodes

The School for Humanity Archive

Explore our archive of NTM’s original podcast, The School for Humanity, created to discuss the greatest challenges humanity faces and help promote those who are helping to find solutions. 

Skip to content