Welcome!

Each week we bring to you a discussion on the latest trends in digital marketing and how you can actually implement these strategies into your organization.

#167 What AI Can’t Replace in Great Marketing with Abe Kasbo and Nick Usborne

Today we’re speaking with Abe Kasbo and Nick Usborne. Abe Kasbo is the Founder and CEO of Verasoni, a global marketing communications advisory, award-winning entrepreneur, and author of Irresponsibly Digital, known for helping C-suite leaders rethink digital-first strategies with purpose, creativity, and measurable impact. Nick Usborne is a digital marketing pioneer and veteran copywriter with over 40 years of experience, training marketers and writers to protect authentic brand stories while responsibly using AI through his “AI + Emotional Intelligence” approach. In this episode, we explore how to blend AI, brand storytelling, and authenticity to create more human, effective marketing.
“These folks are clickocrats, where they just want you to spend all your time and money… on digital products.” -Abe Kasbo
“Brand is your story. That’s the one thing that is unique about you.” -Nick Usborne

About the Episode

Introduction: Meet the Guests

Let’s start with the hosts and guests. The episode kicks off as Jenna (your host) introduces Abe Kasbo and Nick Usborne, both with rich backgrounds and strong opinions about where marketing is headed.

  • Abe Kasbo: CEO of Verasoni, an integrated marketing communications firm. Think “business minds meet creative minds,” a blend of McKinsey and Saatchi, as Abe himself describes.
  • Nick Usborne: Copywriter since the 1980s, founder of Story Aligned, a thought leader in keeping brands emotionally connected—especially as AI takes over content creation.

Reckoning with the Digital-First Mindset

The episode launches with Abe’s book, Irresponsibly Digital, which calls out the dangers of going “digital-first” without purpose or creativity.

What’s Wrong with Digital-First Everything?

Abe points out that there wasn’t a single turning point—just a relentless drumbeat:

  • “We HAVE to be on social.”
  • “We HAVE to be digital.”

“I decided to take a step back and look at that. What does that mean?” — Abe Kasbo

Key Takeaway:
Just chasing the latest platforms with no strategy leads to waste and lost opportunities.

The Shift: Digital Moving Too Fast

Back in 2005, Verasoni was founded at the intersection of traditional and digital marketing. Facebook, Google, and other tech giants started pulling brands online at breakneck speed.

Abe admits he didn’t realize how quickly digital would eclipse traditional methods. But here’s the kicker—he insists the old stuff still works, and digital still has plenty of problems.

Ad Fraud, Clickocracy, and the Cost of Going Digital

The Dark Side: Online Fraud and “Clickocrats”

  • Ad Fraud: Billions lost to fake accounts and bots.
  • Clickocracy: Abe’s term for the endless push by tech and ad platforms to get companies spending digital dollars.

“These folks are clickocrats, where they just want you to spend all your time and money… on digital products.”

Real-World Example: Uber’s $100 Million Blunder

Uber’s CMO once confessed to losing $100 million on digital ads and had no clue how it happened. Let that sink in—a digital-only company, supposedly the cream of the marketing crop, still fell prey to the chaos.

“He was asked, how did you lose it? His answer was, ‘I don’t know.’” — Abe Kasbo

Not Just Uber: Every Platform Is Vulnerable

Abe lists multiple platforms—TikTok included—that have faced big losses. If giant companies struggle, can small businesses or mid-market brands expect better results?

Organic Social: Low Engagement

Abe ran the numbers using Rival IQ:

  • Average engagement on Facebook organic posts? 0.02%.
  • Not “don’t do social,” but be realistic about what you’re expecting.

Breaking Free from Market Herd Mentality

Verasoni’s philosophy pushes back against “market herd mentality”—the temptation to copy what everyone else is doing.

How Do You Actually Escape Trend Chasing?

Abe’s advice:

  • Slow down.
  • Challenge assumptions.
  • Craft a strategy built on originality and trust.

Case Study: From LinkedIn Obsession to Email Power

Abe shares a Michigan client who was dead set on using LinkedIn to grow. Abe disagreed, proposed a different direction (webinars, email), transformed their business, and helped their email list grow from 3,000 to 130,000 in under five years.

“It wasn’t about LinkedIn. It was about acquiring emails… We spent time transforming the business first.”

Trust, Hard Conversations, and Real Client Stories

Building long-term trust isn’t easy, especially when clients have clear visions.Abe’s story:

  • Honest conversations.
  • Telling clients when their assumptions might not work.
  • Earning trust by NOT just following orders.

“Sometimes it takes that hard conversation of, like, ‘I don’t think that’s going to work.’ And it’s a risk.”

Result:
Clients who appreciate honesty get better outcomes and ultimately trust the process more.

The AI Craze: Use It, Don’t Abuse It

Tech buzzwords come and go—AI is just the latest.

“Just think about all of the oxygen that AI right now is sucking out of the air… Same thing happened with digital. It continues with social media.”

Everyone wants to say they’re using AI, sometimes for its own sake. But as Abe puts it:
“Focus isn’t sexy. It’s not digital, but we have to execute on it.”

How to Stay Human in an Automated World

Automation is supposed to boost efficiency, but it often kills the connection that customers really crave.

AI in Customer Experience: Good Intentions, Bad Results

Some clients tried AI phone assistants—and quickly regretted it.

  • Calls got answered, but badly.
  • Contracts had to be canceled.

“…these AI assistants, as good as they think they are, actually suck.”

The Pitfall:
Replacing human interaction with clunky bots leads to frustration for customers.
“Oh, I’m sorry, you’ve chosen the wrong… What are you talking about?”

Abe and Jenna joke about AI answering phones just for the hype. And why are people using AI for grocery lists or condolences messages? It’s overkill.

“I am a certified AI hater. I think it’s really sucking humanity out of humans.” — Jenna

The Verdict: Use Humans Where It Matters

Business is about people, relationships, and authentic interactions.
Don’t make AI your substitute for meaningful human connection.

Aligning Digital Marketing with Purpose and ROI

So what’s the solution?
Step back regularly—at least yearly, ideally every six months.

Abe’s process:

  • Review what worked and what didn’t.
  • Ask: Are our marketing investments truly effective?
  • Look for quality over quantity.

“Take time to assess the marketing investment, the marketing approach. It’s not just what you do, it’s the quality of what you do.”

No easy button or silver bullet—just regular, honest evaluation.

Brand Drift: When AI Makes Us All Sound the Same

Now, let’s switch to Nick Usborne’s perspective:
He’s seen AI lead to “brand drift”—the slow, subtle process of losing what makes your brand feel different.

What Is Brand Drift?

  • AI platforms pull from everything published online.
  • If you don’t give clear instructions, your brand falls into “the sameness trap.”
  • Small changes (in tone, word choice, emotion) stack up, until your brand doesn’t sound like you anymore.

“A brand is the opposite of what you want… You want to maintain differentiation, you want to stand out from the crowd.”

The Business Cost

Loss of trust = Loss of sales.
Customers are possessive about their favorite brands—just look at what happened when Cracker Barrel changed their logo (not AI-related, but the principle holds!).

Building Emotional Intelligence Into AI Workflows

AI writes faster than ever… but it struggles with deep, emotional resonance.

Nick’s advice to marketers:

  • Start with your story.
  • Define your brand narrative (what you say).
  • Clarify your brand voice (how you say it).

“Brand is your story. That’s the one thing that is unique about you.”

Most Marketers Don’t Prompt for Story

Nick’s study of 20 prompt libraries (Google, HubSpot, etc.):

  • 77% about narrative
  • 17% about voice
  • Only 6-7% about story

The story is your moat—nobody can steal your journey.
Don’t make every blog post a retelling, but always filter content through the lens of your unique experience.

The Story/Narrative/Voice Framework

Nick teaches a framework that helps brands scale content without losing their soul.

Step 1: Build Out Deep Instructions for Your Brand

  • Use Custom GPT, Gemini, Claude, HubSpot, or other platforms.
  • Give your AI complete context for your brand story—not just what you say, but why and how.

Example Scenario

It’s not just the words that matter, it’s who is speaking.
Nick’s illustration:

  • Your doctor gives you pills and says, “Trust me.”
  • A shady character does the same.

Same message, same tone—but context means everything!
The “who” is your brand, rooted in your story.

Step 2: Stay Vigilant

  • Review outputs for subtle drift.
  • Course-correct often.
  • Link every piece back to your real brand values.

Scaling Creativity With AI—Is It Even Possible?

Can AI make your marketing more creative, or does it just churn out more blandness?

Nick’s experience:

  • AI has gotten better at tone and emotional connection (with the right prompts).
  • Still struggles with high-performing sales copy—the “conversion magic” is hit or miss.

“If you get into conversation with these models, if you give them sets of instructions… you really can get very high quality writing.”

AI as a Creative Partner

Nick encourages marketers to:

  • Be playful
  • Stay curious
  • Collaborate with AI (don’t just treat it like an answer bot)

Sometimes, AI delivers original insights when you play. Sometimes, it devolves into nonsense. But the back-and-forth process yields surprising ideas.

“It’s like a creative collaboration… When we bounce back and forth like this cool stuff can happen.”

Final Thoughts: Protecting Your Brand in a Tech-Driven World

Across both interviews, the overarching advice is clear:

  • Don’t chase trends blindly.
  • Build your strategy on real business goals and trust.
  • Use AI intentionally—never let it dilute your brand’s story.
  • Step back regularly and assess what’s working (and what isn’t).

Nick’s closing remarks sum it up:

“Protect your brand. It’s a huge part of your value in every way.”

More Episodes

The School for Humanity Archive

Explore our archive of NTM’s original podcast, The School for Humanity, created to discuss the greatest challenges humanity faces and help promote those who are helping to find solutions. 

Skip to content